Trac issueshttps://gitlab.torproject.org/legacy/trac/-/issues2020-06-13T16:19:36Zhttps://gitlab.torproject.org/legacy/trac/-/issues/20505make min_bw configurable in bwauths2020-06-13T16:19:36Zteormake min_bw configurable in bwauthsIn a testing network, there isn't much traffic. So skipping nodes with an observed bandwidth less than 1 MByte/second means that it's easy to skip a large fraction of the network.
It would be helpful if min_bw were a configurable option...In a testing network, there isn't much traffic. So skipping nodes with an observed bandwidth less than 1 MByte/second means that it's easy to skip a large fraction of the network.
It would be helpful if min_bw were a configurable option in bwauthority.cfg. If it is an option, we could consider making the unmeasured node scanner measure all nodes, regardless of bandwidth.https://gitlab.torproject.org/legacy/trac/-/issues/20504When there is only one slice and one scanner, a bwauth runs a second empty slice2020-06-13T16:19:36ZteorWhen there is only one slice and one scanner, a bwauth runs a second empty sliceWhen I run a single bandwidth scanner on less than 50 nodes, configured with:
```
start_pct = 0
stop_pct = 100
nodes_per_slice = 50
```
I get the following log message:
```
NOTICE[Mon Oct 31 04:31:46 2016]:Starting slice for percentiles...When I run a single bandwidth scanner on less than 50 nodes, configured with:
```
start_pct = 0
stop_pct = 100
nodes_per_slice = 50
```
I get the following log message:
```
NOTICE[Mon Oct 31 04:31:46 2016]:Starting slice for percentiles 100-200
NOTICE[Mon Oct 31 04:31:47 2016]:Only 0 exits remain in slice 100-200 after restrictions. ...
NOTICE[Mon Oct 31 04:31:47 2016]:No routers left after restrictions applied: NodeRestrictionList(['UnmeasuredPercentileRestriction(100,200)', 'OrNodeRestriction(["FlagsRestriction([\'BadExit\'],[])", \'ConserveExitsRestriction()\'])', "FlagsRestriction(['Running'],[])"])
```
as well as a successful message for the 0-100 slice.
It seems likely that there is an off by one error, either in the handling of start_pct & stop_pct, or in the handling of nodes_per_slice.https://gitlab.torproject.org/legacy/trac/-/issues/20475Setting bwscanner min_exits to 1 causes no exits to be selected2020-06-13T16:19:35ZteorSetting bwscanner min_exits to 1 causes no exits to be selectedIt looks like there's an off-by-one error in the code that handles this minimun:
```
diff --git a/NetworkScanners/BwAuthority/bwauthority_child.py b/NetworkScanners/BwAuthority/bwauthority_child.py
index a36728f..248c6d0 100755
--- a/Net...It looks like there's an off-by-one error in the code that handles this minimun:
```
diff --git a/NetworkScanners/BwAuthority/bwauthority_child.py b/NetworkScanners/BwAuthority/bwauthority_child.py
index a36728f..248c6d0 100755
--- a/NetworkScanners/BwAuthority/bwauthority_child.py
+++ b/NetworkScanners/BwAuthority/bwauthority_child.py
@@ -67,7 +68,7 @@ __selmgr = PathSupport.SelectionManager(
use_guards=False,
exit_ports=[443],
order_by_ratio=True, # XXX: may be a poor idea for PID control?
- min_exits=10)
+ min_exits=1)
# exit code to indicate scan completion
# make sure to update this in bwauthority.py as well
```https://gitlab.torproject.org/legacy/trac/-/issues/20467bwauth aggregator divides by zero if a node class is missing2020-06-13T16:52:37Zteorbwauth aggregator divides by zero if a node class is missingThe bwauth code expects there to always be a non-zero number of each of "Guard+Exit", "Guard", "Exit", and "Middle" nodes.
In small networks, this isn't always the case:
```
diff --git a/NetworkScanners/BwAuthority/aggregate.py b/Networ...The bwauth code expects there to always be a non-zero number of each of "Guard+Exit", "Guard", "Exit", and "Middle" nodes.
In small networks, this isn't always the case:
```
diff --git a/NetworkScanners/BwAuthority/aggregate.py b/NetworkScanners/BwAuthority/aggregate.py
index 01ea8b5..cae436b 100755
--- a/NetworkScanners/BwAuthority/aggregate.py
+++ b/NetworkScanners/BwAuthority/aggregate.py
@@ -489,10 +489,15 @@ def main(argv):
for cl in ["Guard+Exit", "Guard", "Exit", "Middle"]:
c_nodes = filter(lambda n: n.node_class() == cl, nodes.itervalues())
- true_filt_avg[cl] = sum(map(lambda n: n.filt_bw, c_nodes))/float(len(c_nodes))
- true_strm_avg[cl] = sum(map(lambda n: n.strm_bw, c_nodes))/float(len(c_nodes))
- true_circ_avg[cl] = sum(map(lambda n: (1.0-n.circ_fail_rate),
+ if len(c_nodes) > 0:
+ true_filt_avg[cl] = sum(map(lambda n: n.filt_bw, c_nodes))/float(len(c_nodes))
+ true_strm_avg[cl] = sum(map(lambda n: n.strm_bw, c_nodes))/float(len(c_nodes))
+ true_circ_avg[cl] = sum(map(lambda n: (1.0-n.circ_fail_rate),
c_nodes))/float(len(c_nodes))
+ else:
+ true_filt_avg[cl] = 0.0
+ true_strm_avg[cl] = 0.0
+ true_circ_avg[cl] = 0.0
# FIXME: This may be expensive
pid_tgt_avg[cl] = true_filt_avg[cl]
@@ -835,10 +840,13 @@ def main(argv):
c_nodes = filter(lambda n: n.node_class() == cl, nodes.itervalues())
nc_nodes = filter(lambda n: n.pid_error < 0, c_nodes)
pc_nodes = filter(lambda n: n.pid_error > 0, c_nodes)
- plog("INFO", "Avg "+cl+" pid_error="+str(sum(map(lambda n: n.pid_error, c_nodes))/len(c_nodes)))
- plog("INFO", "Avg "+cl+" |pid_error|="+str(sum(map(lambda n: abs(n.pid_error), c_nodes))/len(c_nodes)))
- plog("INFO", "Avg "+cl+" +pid_error=+"+str(sum(map(lambda n: n.pid_error, pc_nodes))/len(pc_nodes)))
- plog("INFO", "Avg "+cl+" -pid_error="+str(sum(map(lambda n: n.pid_error, nc_nodes))/len(nc_nodes)))
+ if len(c_nodes) > 0:
+ plog("INFO", "Avg "+cl+" pid_error="+str(sum(map(lambda n: n.pid_error, c_nodes))/len(c_nodes)))
+ plog("INFO", "Avg "+cl+" |pid_error|="+str(sum(map(lambda n: abs(n.pid_error), c_nodes))/len(c_nodes)))
+ if len(pc_nodes) > 0:
+ plog("INFO", "Avg "+cl+" +pid_error=+"+str(sum(map(lambda n: n.pid_error, pc_nodes))/len(pc_nodes)))
+ if len(nc_nodes) > 0:
+ plog("INFO", "Avg "+cl+" -pid_error="+str(sum(map(lambda n: n.pid_error, nc_nodes))/len(nc_nodes)))
n_nodes = filter(lambda n: n.pid_error < 0, nodes.itervalues())
p_nodes = filter(lambda n: n.pid_error > 0, nodes.itervalues())
```
We could fix this by guarding every division by a length with a check.
Refactoring would make this much easier.Aaron GibsonAaron Gibsonhttps://gitlab.torproject.org/legacy/trac/-/issues/20466Replacing python path sometimes breaks bwauths2020-06-13T16:19:34ZteorReplacing python path sometimes breaks bwauthsWhen I let run_scan.sh replace my python path, the script can't find necessary libraries. When I prepend instead, it works.
I'm not sure whether this means my pip / python install is broken, or the bwauth code is.When I let run_scan.sh replace my python path, the script can't find necessary libraries. When I prepend instead, it works.
I'm not sure whether this means my pip / python install is broken, or the bwauth code is.https://gitlab.torproject.org/legacy/trac/-/issues/20457Turn pathbias off in bwauth tors2020-06-13T16:52:37ZteorTurn pathbias off in bwauth torsWhen running the bandwidth scanner with recent tor versions, the pathbias detector complains about circuit state at notice level.
This could quickly fill the logs.
I suggest we add this to the bottom of tor.1/torrc and tor.2/torrc:
```
...When running the bandwidth scanner with recent tor versions, the pathbias detector complains about circuit state at notice level.
This could quickly fill the logs.
I suggest we add this to the bottom of tor.1/torrc and tor.2/torrc:
```
# Turn pathbias off, so it doesn't flood the logs
UseEntryGuards 0
```Aaron GibsonAaron Gibsonhttps://gitlab.torproject.org/legacy/trac/-/issues/20455bwauth cron scripts need to be run in the BwAuthority directory2020-06-13T16:19:33Zteorbwauth cron scripts need to be run in the BwAuthority directoryThis can be fixed by adding a cd /home/bwauth/torflow/NetworkScanners/BwAuthority before the command.This can be fixed by adding a cd /home/bwauth/torflow/NetworkScanners/BwAuthority before the command.https://gitlab.torproject.org/legacy/trac/-/issues/20454Work out why BwAuth setup.sh doesn't work on macOS2020-06-13T16:19:33ZteorWork out why BwAuth setup.sh doesn't work on macOSWhen I run the individual steps, they work fine. But the script itself seems to exit without producing any output.When I run the individual steps, they work fine. But the script itself seems to exit without producing any output.Aaron GibsonAaron Gibsonhttps://gitlab.torproject.org/legacy/trac/-/issues/20453Update bwauth setup.sh to use tor 0.2.8.92020-06-13T16:19:33ZteorUpdate bwauth setup.sh to use tor 0.2.8.9Currently, the bwauth script uses tor 0.2.6, which is getting pretty old.
There are performance and security improvements in 0.2.8, so we sould use that.Currently, the bwauth script uses tor 0.2.6, which is getting pretty old.
There are performance and security improvements in 0.2.8, so we sould use that.Aaron GibsonAaron Gibsonhttps://gitlab.torproject.org/legacy/trac/-/issues/20452macOS and BSD don't support readlink -f in bwauth setup.sh2020-06-13T16:19:32ZteormacOS and BSD don't support readlink -f in bwauth setup.shBut plain readlink seems to work just fine.But plain readlink seems to work just fine.https://gitlab.torproject.org/legacy/trac/-/issues/17810TorFlow should ignore self-reported bandwidths when measuring relays2020-06-13T16:19:31ZRob JansenTorFlow should ignore self-reported bandwidths when measuring relaysA relay that self-reports high bandwidth values will get an inflated consensus weight. I believe that TorFlow somehow uses the self-reported values when producing a measurement result for a relay. We should fix TorFlow so that it better ...A relay that self-reports high bandwidth values will get an inflated consensus weight. I believe that TorFlow somehow uses the self-reported values when producing a measurement result for a relay. We should fix TorFlow so that it better handles self-reported values in order to prevent a relay from accidentally or maliciously getting uncharacteristically high consensus weights.https://gitlab.torproject.org/legacy/trac/-/issues/17482The longer a bwauth runs, the slower it goes2020-06-13T16:19:30ZTom Rittertom@ritter.vgThe longer a bwauth runs, the slower it goesThis is an anecdote, but it looks suspicious. The below indicates the time it takes a slice to complete. As you can see the bwauth slowed down considerably for each slice.
I'm going to restart my bwauth completely and see if this is re...This is an anecdote, but it looks suspicious. The below indicates the time it takes a slice to complete. As you can see the bwauth slowed down considerably for each slice.
I'm going to restart my bwauth completely and see if this is really the case. https://bwauth.ritter.vg/bwauth/AA_scanner_loop_times.txt has the data
```
Scanner 1
NOTICE[Tue Aug 18 15:29:50 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 0.0-0.796812749004
NOTICE[Wed Aug 19 16:58:34 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 0.0-0.802568218299
NOTICE[Thu Aug 20 20:19:46 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 0.0-0.805282654212
NOTICE[Fri Aug 21 22:53:58 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 0.0-0.808146112817
NOTICE[Sat Aug 22 19:45:05 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 0.0-0.811820100666
NOTICE[Sun Aug 23 23:11:28 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 0.0-0.817260542661
NOTICE[Mon Aug 24 23:20:34 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 0.0-0.808538163001
NOTICE[Wed Aug 26 00:12:32 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 0.0-0.807232805941
NOTICE[Thu Aug 27 04:19:16 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 0.0-0.813802083333
NOTICE[Fri Aug 28 03:36:08 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 0.0-0.80051232789
NOTICE[Sat Aug 29 08:22:00 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 0.0-0.790763877906
NOTICE[Sun Aug 30 06:40:47 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 0.0-0.795165394402
NOTICE[Mon Aug 31 03:21:42 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 0.0-0.800897004645
NOTICE[Tue Sep 01 04:48:47 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 0.0-0.787773751379
NOTICE[Wed Sep 02 06:59:38 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 0.0-0.781983109165
NOTICE[Thu Sep 03 03:03:56 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 0.0-0.787897888434
NOTICE[Fri Sep 04 01:59:13 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 0.0-0.782472613459
NOTICE[Fri Sep 04 21:36:50 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 0.0-0.787153652393
NOTICE[Sat Sep 05 16:31:05 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 0.0-0.779423226812
NOTICE[Sun Sep 06 18:13:30 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 0.0-0.782962730974
NOTICE[Mon Sep 07 22:10:37 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 0.0-0.78727759408
NOTICE[Wed Sep 09 04:06:19 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 0.0-0.783085356304
NOTICE[Thu Sep 10 04:59:14 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 0.0-0.787773751379
NOTICE[Fri Sep 11 11:19:43 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 0.0-0.794659885569
NOTICE[Sat Sep 12 12:38:24 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 0.0-0.778331257783
NOTICE[Sun Sep 13 15:39:58 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 0.0-0.777484061577
NOTICE[Mon Sep 14 19:50:39 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 0.0-0.777000777001
NOTICE[Tue Sep 15 21:20:55 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 0.0-0.786905886056
NOTICE[Wed Sep 16 23:31:45 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 0.0-0.785669390321
NOTICE[Fri Sep 18 04:51:04 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 0.0-0.772797527048
NOTICE[Sat Sep 19 05:48:45 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 0.0-0.765931372549
NOTICE[Sun Sep 20 10:02:27 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 0.0-0.764292265362
NOTICE[Mon Sep 21 16:25:35 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 0.0-0.768521364894
NOTICE[Tue Sep 22 18:09:54 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 0.0-0.77136686208
NOTICE[Thu Sep 24 00:35:41 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 0.0-0.778816199377
NOTICE[Fri Sep 25 06:21:39 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 0.0-0.774713356058
NOTICE[Wed Sep 30 16:18:36 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 0.0-0.761614623001
NOTICE[Wed Oct 07 09:05:01 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 0.0-0.759301442673
NOTICE[Mon Oct 12 16:48:58 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 0.0-0.763591936469
NOTICE[Sun Oct 18 15:41:41 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 0.0-0.762427569381
NOTICE[Fri Oct 23 19:10:47 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 0.0-0.76103500761
NOTICE[Fri Oct 30 08:32:12 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 0.0-0.7611508601
Scanner 2
NOTICE[Tue Aug 18 15:29:50 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 12.0-12.796812749
NOTICE[Wed Aug 19 12:31:13 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 12.0-12.7959248647
NOTICE[Thu Aug 20 06:48:47 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 12.0-12.798977309
NOTICE[Fri Aug 21 01:07:11 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 12.0-12.8033419023
NOTICE[Fri Aug 21 19:12:06 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 12.0-12.8011536613
NOTICE[Sat Aug 22 12:09:06 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 12.0-12.798977309
NOTICE[Sun Aug 23 04:53:07 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 12.0-12.8014104824
NOTICE[Sun Aug 23 22:37:52 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 12.0-12.8172605427
NOTICE[Mon Aug 24 20:21:50 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 12.0-12.8047642041
NOTICE[Tue Aug 25 15:49:19 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 12.0-12.7930214116
NOTICE[Wed Aug 26 08:31:46 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 12.0-12.7960515841
NOTICE[Thu Aug 27 04:24:20 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 12.0-12.8016674683
NOTICE[Fri Aug 28 00:27:17 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 12.0-12.8038585209
NOTICE[Fri Aug 28 18:47:20 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 12.0-12.7963051441
NOTICE[Sat Aug 29 12:40:46 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 12.0-12.7892659826
NOTICE[Sun Aug 30 05:21:13 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 12.0-12.7959248647
NOTICE[Mon Aug 31 00:23:24 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 12.0-12.8065817067
NOTICE[Mon Aug 31 19:21:53 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 12.0-12.810241452
NOTICE[Tue Sep 01 14:11:21 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 12.0-12.7790588969
NOTICE[Wed Sep 02 14:25:14 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 12.0-12.7714858818
NOTICE[Thu Sep 03 08:32:48 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 12.0-12.7818608288
NOTICE[Fri Sep 04 01:52:49 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 12.0-12.7824726135
NOTICE[Fri Sep 04 19:04:22 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 12.0-12.7800312012
NOTICE[Sat Sep 05 10:47:22 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 12.0-12.7749535028
NOTICE[Sun Sep 06 03:44:38 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 12.0-12.7788161994
NOTICE[Sun Sep 06 21:24:43 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 12.0-12.788519161
NOTICE[Mon Sep 07 16:55:43 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 12.0-12.777000777
NOTICE[Tue Sep 08 12:29:49 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 12.0-12.7731560229
NOTICE[Wed Sep 09 10:33:30 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 12.0-12.7846829881
NOTICE[Thu Sep 10 04:18:57 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 12.0-12.8026970621
NOTICE[Thu Sep 10 22:45:56 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 12.0-12.7960515841
NOTICE[Fri Sep 11 18:09:37 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 12.0-12.7856693903
NOTICE[Sat Sep 12 11:36:51 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 12.0-12.7797878977
NOTICE[Sun Sep 13 04:54:44 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 12.0-12.7819831092
NOTICE[Sun Sep 13 22:34:11 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 12.0-12.7928956549
NOTICE[Mon Sep 14 15:33:44 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 12.0-12.7672241829
NOTICE[Tue Sep 15 06:55:11 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 12.0-12.7714858818
NOTICE[Wed Sep 16 00:42:57 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 12.0-12.7830853563
NOTICE[Wed Sep 16 18:19:48 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 12.0-12.7784524366
NOTICE[Thu Sep 17 15:46:07 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 12.0-12.7668711656
NOTICE[Fri Sep 18 09:01:22 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 12.0-12.7686395081
NOTICE[Sat Sep 19 01:38:35 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 12.0-12.7731560229
NOTICE[Sat Sep 19 18:27:38 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 12.0-12.7706535142
NOTICE[Sun Sep 20 13:12:07 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 12.0-12.7598784195
NOTICE[Mon Sep 21 07:04:56 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 12.0-12.7711289328
NOTICE[Tue Sep 22 05:57:49 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 12.0-12.7723200494
NOTICE[Wed Sep 23 01:54:34 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 12.0-12.7772423442
NOTICE[Wed Sep 23 20:43:27 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 12.0-12.7776049767
NOTICE[Thu Sep 24 16:36:57 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 12.0-12.7689941556
NOTICE[Fri Sep 25 10:58:14 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 12.0-12.7648768548
NOTICE[Sun Sep 27 20:40:20 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 12.0-12.7702973348
NOTICE[Thu Oct 01 19:51:18 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 12.0-12.7572315614
NOTICE[Mon Oct 05 20:54:34 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 12.0-12.7572315614
NOTICE[Fri Oct 09 14:38:57 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 12.0-12.7558578987
NOTICE[Mon Oct 12 22:16:11 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 12.0-12.773993808
NOTICE[Fri Oct 16 03:32:41 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 12.0-12.7691124442
NOTICE[Mon Oct 19 19:47:23 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 12.0-12.7723200494
NOTICE[Fri Oct 23 04:27:55 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 12.0-12.7667535654
NOTICE[Mon Oct 26 16:12:42 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 12.0-12.7526719855
NOTICE[Fri Oct 30 14:48:27 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 12.0-12.7551729346
Scanner 3
NOTICE[Tue Aug 18 15:29:50 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 25.0-25.796812749
NOTICE[Wed Aug 19 05:40:42 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 25.0-25.8043758044
NOTICE[Wed Aug 19 22:20:39 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 25.0-25.8122157245
NOTICE[Thu Aug 20 13:00:19 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 25.0-25.7927699382
NOTICE[Fri Aug 21 03:04:21 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 25.0-25.8008970046
NOTICE[Fri Aug 21 17:49:47 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 25.0-25.8003841844
NOTICE[Sat Aug 22 06:22:23 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 25.0-25.8023106547
NOTICE[Sat Aug 22 20:02:49 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 25.0-25.8118201007
NOTICE[Sun Aug 23 10:55:59 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 25.0-25.7946598856
NOTICE[Mon Aug 24 16:38:14 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 25.0-25.7969397514
NOTICE[Tue Aug 25 10:47:08 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 25.0-25.7945336088
NOTICE[Wed Aug 26 06:02:19 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 25.0-25.7969397514
NOTICE[Thu Aug 27 01:37:08 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 25.0-25.8008970046
NOTICE[Thu Aug 27 18:06:48 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 25.0-25.800768738
NOTICE[Fri Aug 28 08:59:36 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 25.0-25.7932730446
NOTICE[Fri Aug 28 23:36:42 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 25.0-25.8068420203
NOTICE[Sat Aug 29 14:12:47 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 25.0-25.7912644406
NOTICE[Sun Aug 30 04:04:07 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 25.0-25.7965588657
NOTICE[Sun Aug 30 21:00:52 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 25.0-25.8050233457
NOTICE[Mon Aug 31 12:15:17 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 25.0-25.7920164739
NOTICE[Tue Sep 01 03:04:05 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 25.0-25.7900142203
NOTICE[Tue Sep 01 18:51:53 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 25.0-25.7881462799
NOTICE[Wed Sep 02 11:03:56 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 25.0-25.7790588969
NOTICE[Thu Sep 03 02:11:08 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 25.0-25.7888923951
NOTICE[Thu Sep 03 16:46:37 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 25.0-25.7765180929
NOTICE[Fri Sep 04 06:29:56 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 25.0-25.7794232268
NOTICE[Fri Sep 04 21:13:09 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 25.0-25.7854225573
NOTICE[Sat Sep 05 11:43:17 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 25.0-25.7751937984
NOTICE[Sun Sep 06 02:48:59 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 25.0-25.7819831092
NOTICE[Sun Sep 06 16:37:39 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 25.0-25.777000777
NOTICE[Mon Sep 07 06:12:31 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 25.0-25.7795447459
NOTICE[Tue Sep 08 01:37:42 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 25.0-25.7848061529
NOTICE[Tue Sep 08 20:51:59 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 25.0-25.7859163785
NOTICE[Wed Sep 09 10:18:04 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 25.0-25.7848061529
NOTICE[Thu Sep 10 01:12:17 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 25.0-25.7928956549
NOTICE[Thu Sep 10 15:22:02 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 25.0-25.7818608288
NOTICE[Fri Sep 11 05:26:01 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 25.0-25.7872775941
NOTICE[Fri Sep 11 18:57:44 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 25.0-25.7840677435
NOTICE[Sat Sep 12 12:18:40 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 25.0-25.7784524366
NOTICE[Sun Sep 13 05:06:59 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 25.0-25.7819831092
NOTICE[Sun Sep 13 21:10:44 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 25.0-25.786163522
NOTICE[Mon Sep 14 10:19:38 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 25.0-25.7778469197
NOTICE[Tue Sep 15 00:04:30 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 25.0-25.7816163827
NOTICE[Tue Sep 15 14:58:10 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 25.0-25.7695859628
NOTICE[Wed Sep 16 03:21:02 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 25.0-25.7786949073
NOTICE[Wed Sep 16 20:02:27 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 25.0-25.7808839606
NOTICE[Thu Sep 17 11:02:49 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 25.0-25.7668711656
NOTICE[Fri Sep 18 04:28:53 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 25.0-25.772797527
NOTICE[Fri Sep 18 18:58:12 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 25.0-25.7700600647
NOTICE[Sat Sep 19 06:01:17 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 25.0-25.7659313725
NOTICE[Sat Sep 19 21:17:48 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 25.0-25.7881462799
NOTICE[Sun Sep 20 11:19:14 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 25.0-25.7623113279
NOTICE[Sun Sep 20 23:14:46 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 25.0-25.7790588969
NOTICE[Mon Sep 21 12:47:26 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 25.0-25.7656967841
NOTICE[Tue Sep 22 03:42:40 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 25.0-25.7754342432
NOTICE[Tue Sep 22 21:24:11 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 25.0-25.7779679477
NOTICE[Wed Sep 23 10:49:55 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 25.0-25.7653451707
NOTICE[Thu Sep 24 02:34:30 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 25.0-25.7765180929
NOTICE[Thu Sep 24 18:51:55 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 25.0-25.7710100231
NOTICE[Fri Sep 25 08:51:43 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 25.0-25.7687576876
NOTICE[Sat Sep 26 23:06:39 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 25.0-25.7762769756
NOTICE[Tue Sep 29 18:51:41 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 25.0-25.7644091118
NOTICE[Fri Oct 02 05:35:04 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 25.0-25.7526719855
NOTICE[Sun Oct 04 18:01:26 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 25.0-25.750863493
NOTICE[Wed Oct 07 06:31:32 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 25.0-25.7609191904
NOTICE[Fri Oct 09 18:35:38 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 25.0-25.7655795437
NOTICE[Mon Oct 12 09:43:50 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 25.0-25.7641754547
NOTICE[Thu Oct 15 01:12:28 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 25.0-25.7732755954
NOTICE[Sun Oct 18 00:17:06 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 25.0-25.7749535028
NOTICE[Tue Oct 20 09:17:39 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 25.0-25.7942811755
NOTICE[Fri Oct 23 01:10:41 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 25.0-25.7710100231
NOTICE[Sun Oct 25 15:04:24 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 25.0-25.7519927809
NOTICE[Wed Oct 28 07:56:27 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 25.0-25.7563152322
Scanner 4
NOTICE[Tue Aug 18 15:29:51 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 37.0-37.796812749
NOTICE[Wed Aug 19 18:55:41 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 37.0-37.8078849572
NOTICE[Thu Aug 20 21:43:01 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 37.0-37.804893754
NOTICE[Fri Aug 21 19:56:54 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 37.0-37.803083842
NOTICE[Sat Aug 22 13:20:12 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 37.0-37.7988496565
NOTICE[Sun Aug 23 07:17:05 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 37.0-37.8028259473
NOTICE[Mon Aug 24 00:02:25 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 37.0-37.8191349934
NOTICE[Mon Aug 24 17:18:12 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 37.0-37.8015389548
NOTICE[Tue Aug 25 13:29:35 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 37.0-37.789016885
NOTICE[Wed Aug 26 12:59:50 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 37.0-37.7906388362
NOTICE[Thu Aug 27 09:15:07 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 37.0-37.7940289027
NOTICE[Fri Aug 28 05:45:10 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 37.0-37.7970667942
NOTICE[Fri Aug 28 22:28:42 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 37.0-37.8054123711
NOTICE[Sat Aug 29 16:36:24 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 37.0-37.7966857871
NOTICE[Sun Aug 30 10:05:57 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 37.0-37.7917656374
NOTICE[Mon Aug 31 05:08:28 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 37.0-37.7975753709
NOTICE[Tue Sep 01 00:01:05 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 37.0-37.8006405124
NOTICE[Tue Sep 01 18:23:18 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 37.0-37.7883948281
NOTICE[Wed Sep 02 16:19:49 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 37.0-37.7911392405
NOTICE[Thu Sep 03 09:53:02 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 37.0-37.7806401249
NOTICE[Fri Sep 04 04:35:05 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 37.0-37.7814942169
NOTICE[Fri Sep 04 22:33:51 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 37.0-37.7887679445
NOTICE[Sat Sep 05 16:36:07 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 37.0-37.7794232268
NOTICE[Sun Sep 06 11:18:40 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 37.0-37.7723200494
NOTICE[Mon Sep 07 07:30:49 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 37.0-37.7768800497
NOTICE[Tue Sep 08 08:11:47 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 37.0-37.7778469197
NOTICE[Wed Sep 09 05:38:50 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 37.0-37.785299199
NOTICE[Thu Sep 10 00:00:53 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 37.0-37.7960515841
NOTICE[Thu Sep 10 17:42:29 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 37.0-37.7870297497
NOTICE[Fri Sep 11 11:23:17 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 37.0-37.7860399308
NOTICE[Sat Sep 12 07:33:17 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 37.0-37.7821054278
NOTICE[Sun Sep 13 02:39:05 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 37.0-37.7860399308
NOTICE[Sun Sep 13 22:57:00 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 37.0-37.7928956549
NOTICE[Mon Sep 14 15:59:01 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 37.0-37.7672241829
NOTICE[Tue Sep 15 14:53:06 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 37.0-37.7695859628
NOTICE[Wed Sep 16 08:21:36 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 37.0-37.7712478791
NOTICE[Thu Sep 17 04:39:13 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 37.0-37.7777259294
NOTICE[Fri Sep 18 01:28:55 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 37.0-37.7759155804
NOTICE[Fri Sep 18 19:33:30 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 37.0-37.7712478791
NOTICE[Sat Sep 19 12:47:10 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 37.0-37.7632422531
NOTICE[Sun Sep 20 07:35:43 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 37.0-37.7638252368
NOTICE[Mon Sep 21 01:31:41 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 37.0-37.7748334108
NOTICE[Mon Sep 21 19:44:13 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 37.0-37.7772423442
NOTICE[Tue Sep 22 13:21:36 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 37.0-37.7688759034
NOTICE[Wed Sep 23 10:10:24 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 37.0-37.7688759034
NOTICE[Thu Sep 24 06:32:15 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 37.0-37.7717240315
NOTICE[Fri Sep 25 00:50:22 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 37.0-37.7733952049
NOTICE[Fri Sep 25 21:19:16 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 37.0-37.773634535
NOTICE[Mon Sep 28 19:02:03 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 37.0-37.7682851875
NOTICE[Thu Oct 01 13:50:42 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 37.0-37.7454897868
NOTICE[Sun Oct 04 09:41:02 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 37.0-37.7429420505
NOTICE[Wed Oct 07 11:22:39 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 37.0-37.754944889
NOTICE[Sat Oct 10 09:21:50 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 37.0-37.7584951456
NOTICE[Tue Oct 13 14:28:18 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 37.0-37.7614986293
NOTICE[Fri Oct 16 13:23:57 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 37.0-37.7634753397
NOTICE[Mon Oct 19 10:33:07 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 37.0-37.7647598654
NOTICE[Thu Oct 22 00:08:33 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 37.0-37.7732755954
NOTICE[Sat Oct 24 22:58:12 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 37.0-37.7674597084
NOTICE[Wed Oct 28 01:42:42 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 37.0-37.7612667479
Scanner 5
NOTICE[Tue Aug 18 15:29:50 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 50.0-50.796812749
NOTICE[Wed Aug 19 04:05:01 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 50.0-50.8029548739
NOTICE[Wed Aug 19 18:55:40 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 50.0-50.8078849572
NOTICE[Thu Aug 20 09:27:46 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 50.0-50.798977309
NOTICE[Fri Aug 21 00:18:32 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 50.0-50.8172605427
NOTICE[Fri Aug 21 14:31:36 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 50.0-50.7985944737
NOTICE[Sat Aug 22 03:06:17 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 50.0-50.804893754
NOTICE[Sat Aug 22 16:50:20 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 50.0-50.8017960231
NOTICE[Sun Aug 23 07:34:01 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 50.0-50.7960515841
NOTICE[Sun Aug 23 23:45:02 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 50.0-50.819000819
NOTICE[Mon Aug 24 15:39:26 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 50.0-50.7945336088
NOTICE[Tue Aug 25 07:18:59 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 50.0-50.7983394539
NOTICE[Tue Aug 25 21:57:12 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 50.0-50.8051529791
NOTICE[Wed Aug 26 12:37:28 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 50.0-50.7907638779
NOTICE[Thu Aug 27 05:19:43 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 50.0-50.7966857871
NOTICE[Thu Aug 27 19:34:34 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 50.0-50.8025682183
NOTICE[Fri Aug 28 09:08:01 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 50.0-50.7932730446
NOTICE[Fri Aug 28 22:08:18 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 50.0-50.8046346958
NOTICE[Sat Aug 29 12:06:34 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 50.0-50.790513834
NOTICE[Sun Aug 30 01:47:08 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 50.0-50.8039877794
NOTICE[Sun Aug 30 23:20:26 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 50.0-50.8080155139
NOTICE[Mon Aug 31 16:32:28 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 50.0-50.7974481659
NOTICE[Tue Sep 01 08:17:53 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 50.0-50.7845598619
NOTICE[Wed Sep 02 01:21:10 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 50.0-50.7970667942
NOTICE[Wed Sep 02 20:01:27 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 50.0-50.7869058861
NOTICE[Thu Sep 03 13:01:44 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 50.0-50.772797527
NOTICE[Fri Sep 04 04:46:40 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 50.0-50.7814942169
NOTICE[Fri Sep 04 19:40:53 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 50.0-50.7830853563
NOTICE[Sat Sep 05 11:53:26 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 50.0-50.775073632
NOTICE[Sun Sep 06 04:10:45 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 50.0-50.7788161994
NOTICE[Sun Sep 06 17:23:57 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 50.0-50.782962731
NOTICE[Mon Sep 07 07:20:15 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 50.0-50.77675936
NOTICE[Tue Sep 08 09:20:31 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 50.0-50.7772423442
NOTICE[Wed Sep 09 09:01:59 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 50.0-50.7859163785
NOTICE[Thu Sep 10 00:39:48 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 50.0-50.7931472081
NOTICE[Thu Sep 10 20:55:46 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 50.0-50.7906388362
NOTICE[Fri Sep 11 12:20:56 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 50.0-50.7797878977
NOTICE[Sat Sep 12 05:55:09 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 50.0-50.7846829881
NOTICE[Sat Sep 12 21:18:46 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 50.0-50.7911392405
NOTICE[Sun Sep 13 10:38:57 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 50.0-50.7772423442
NOTICE[Mon Sep 14 02:48:32 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 50.0-50.7892659826
NOTICE[Mon Sep 14 19:40:08 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 50.0-50.777000777
NOTICE[Tue Sep 15 11:48:59 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 50.0-50.7658140603
NOTICE[Wed Sep 16 03:20:33 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 50.0-50.7807620237
NOTICE[Wed Sep 16 21:32:39 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 50.0-50.7846829881
NOTICE[Thu Sep 17 16:14:43 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 50.0-50.7667535654
NOTICE[Fri Sep 18 08:50:39 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 50.0-50.7688759034
NOTICE[Fri Sep 18 23:17:05 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 50.0-50.7783312578
NOTICE[Sat Sep 19 13:38:31 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 50.0-50.7637085688
NOTICE[Sun Sep 20 02:35:09 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 50.0-50.7698229407
NOTICE[Sun Sep 20 18:34:18 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 50.0-50.7725587145
NOTICE[Mon Sep 21 09:49:00 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 50.0-50.7679311934
NOTICE[Tue Sep 22 02:04:30 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 50.0-50.7789375292
NOTICE[Tue Sep 22 16:42:18 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 50.0-50.7687576876
NOTICE[Wed Sep 23 06:48:29 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 50.0-50.7697044335
NOTICE[Wed Sep 23 20:34:13 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 50.0-50.7774840616
NOTICE[Thu Sep 24 11:33:25 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 50.0-50.7647598654
NOTICE[Fri Sep 25 01:32:03 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 50.0-50.7726781023
NOTICE[Fri Sep 25 15:38:55 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 50.0-50.7666360012
NOTICE[Sun Sep 27 16:09:40 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 50.0-50.7625438463
NOTICE[Wed Sep 30 00:30:20 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 50.0-50.7691124442
NOTICE[Fri Oct 02 16:24:38 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 50.0-50.7459346561
NOTICE[Mon Oct 05 05:53:25 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 50.0-50.751653638
NOTICE[Wed Oct 07 17:42:39 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 50.0-50.7633587786
NOTICE[Sat Oct 10 05:17:35 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 50.0-50.7751937984
NOTICE[Mon Oct 12 18:28:46 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 50.0-50.7666360012
NOTICE[Thu Oct 15 03:26:40 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 50.0-50.7682851875
NOTICE[Sat Oct 17 12:06:29 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 50.0-50.7640586797
NOTICE[Mon Oct 19 23:50:03 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 50.0-50.7754342432
NOTICE[Thu Oct 22 16:01:34 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 50.0-50.7614986293
NOTICE[Sun Oct 25 06:45:50 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 50.0-50.7544892108
NOTICE[Tue Oct 27 17:24:31 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 50.0-50.7578053956
NOTICE[Fri Oct 30 03:52:21 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 50.0-50.7644091118
Scanner 6
NOTICE[Tue Aug 18 15:29:48 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 62.0-62.796812749
NOTICE[Wed Aug 19 09:35:13 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 62.0-62.800768738
NOTICE[Thu Aug 20 01:34:37 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 62.0-62.8122157245
NOTICE[Thu Aug 20 17:47:48 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 62.0-62.8033419023
NOTICE[Fri Aug 21 08:04:31 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 62.0-62.7963051441
NOTICE[Fri Aug 21 21:06:50 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 62.0-62.8024394158
NOTICE[Sat Aug 22 11:09:05 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 62.0-62.7966857871
NOTICE[Sun Aug 23 01:16:58 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 62.0-62.8127438231
NOTICE[Sun Aug 23 16:54:23 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 62.0-62.8039877794
NOTICE[Mon Aug 24 07:36:40 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 62.0-62.8039877794
NOTICE[Tue Aug 25 00:31:18 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 62.0-62.8045052293
NOTICE[Tue Aug 25 16:03:25 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 62.0-62.7928956549
NOTICE[Wed Aug 26 05:12:10 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 62.0-62.7977026165
NOTICE[Wed Aug 26 21:46:51 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 62.0-62.8051529791
NOTICE[Thu Aug 27 11:20:08 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 62.0-62.7891414141
NOTICE[Fri Aug 28 02:18:49 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 62.0-62.8203445447
NOTICE[Fri Aug 28 17:55:57 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 62.0-62.7954183901
NOTICE[Sat Aug 29 08:39:27 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 62.0-62.7906388362
NOTICE[Sat Aug 29 23:48:59 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 62.0-62.8090614887
NOTICE[Sun Aug 30 15:34:44 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 62.0-62.7939028263
NOTICE[Mon Aug 31 09:01:05 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 62.0-62.7950389569
NOTICE[Tue Sep 01 00:22:43 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 62.0-62.7949125596
NOTICE[Tue Sep 01 15:31:59 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 62.0-62.7789375292
NOTICE[Wed Sep 02 09:33:09 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 62.0-62.7784524366
NOTICE[Thu Sep 03 00:39:12 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 62.0-62.7900142203
NOTICE[Thu Sep 03 18:33:46 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 62.0-62.78015291
NOTICE[Fri Sep 04 08:29:40 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 62.0-62.7753140022
NOTICE[Sat Sep 05 00:48:03 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 62.0-62.7859163785
NOTICE[Sat Sep 05 17:46:18 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 62.0-62.7819831092
NOTICE[Sun Sep 06 08:54:01 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 62.0-62.7733952049
NOTICE[Sun Sep 06 23:35:05 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 62.0-62.7927699382
NOTICE[Mon Sep 07 15:58:26 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 62.0-62.773634535
NOTICE[Tue Sep 08 11:44:15 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 62.0-62.7743534149
NOTICE[Wed Sep 09 03:17:23 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 62.0-62.7832080201
NOTICE[Thu Sep 10 02:26:10 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 62.0-62.7898894155
NOTICE[Thu Sep 10 23:34:38 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 62.0-62.7964319847
NOTICE[Fri Sep 11 18:52:55 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 62.0-62.7841907152
NOTICE[Sat Sep 12 17:26:56 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 62.0-62.7855459544
NOTICE[Sun Sep 13 09:53:45 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 62.0-62.7772423442
NOTICE[Mon Sep 14 02:42:23 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 62.0-62.7892659826
NOTICE[Mon Sep 14 19:20:49 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 62.0-62.7772423442
NOTICE[Tue Sep 15 14:49:51 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 62.0-62.7695859628
NOTICE[Wed Sep 16 06:20:49 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 62.0-62.7744733581
NOTICE[Thu Sep 17 05:25:18 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 62.0-62.7731560229
NOTICE[Thu Sep 17 22:23:01 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 62.0-62.7811279488
NOTICE[Fri Sep 18 14:04:08 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 62.0-62.7602250266
NOTICE[Sat Sep 19 04:25:38 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 62.0-62.7695859628
NOTICE[Sat Sep 19 20:20:18 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 62.0-62.7755545215
NOTICE[Sun Sep 20 14:27:38 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 62.0-62.7623113279
NOTICE[Mon Sep 21 04:02:33 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 62.0-62.7729169887
NOTICE[Mon Sep 21 20:29:49 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 62.0-62.7772423442
NOTICE[Tue Sep 22 11:41:47 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 62.0-62.7666360012
NOTICE[Wed Sep 23 04:38:29 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 62.0-62.772797527
NOTICE[Wed Sep 23 21:30:46 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 62.0-62.7794232268
NOTICE[Thu Sep 24 15:31:28 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 62.0-62.7639419404
NOTICE[Fri Sep 25 05:36:07 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 62.0-62.7676953785
NOTICE[Sat Sep 26 01:23:51 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 62.0-62.7730364873
NOTICE[Mon Sep 28 17:35:16 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 62.0-62.7666360012
NOTICE[Thu Oct 01 14:33:57 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 62.0-62.7443799315
NOTICE[Sun Oct 04 08:43:19 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 62.0-62.7433838834
NOTICE[Tue Oct 06 20:50:46 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 62.0-62.7710100231
NOTICE[Fri Oct 09 12:50:46 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 62.0-62.756429652
NOTICE[Mon Oct 12 06:00:29 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 62.0-62.7661661048
NOTICE[Thu Oct 15 00:37:00 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 62.0-62.7730364873
NOTICE[Sat Oct 17 17:20:48 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 62.0-62.7702973348
NOTICE[Tue Oct 20 09:14:23 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 62.0-62.7675775253
NOTICE[Fri Oct 23 02:02:36 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 62.0-62.7731560229
NOTICE[Sun Oct 25 22:05:55 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 62.0-62.7638252368
NOTICE[Wed Oct 28 19:53:19 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 62.0-62.7586102261
Scanner 7
NOTICE[Tue Aug 18 15:29:49 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 75.0-75.796812749
NOTICE[Wed Aug 19 03:25:07 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 75.0-75.803083842
NOTICE[Wed Aug 19 17:34:49 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 75.0-75.8084074373
NOTICE[Thu Aug 20 05:31:02 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 75.0-75.8012820513
NOTICE[Thu Aug 20 18:32:47 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 75.0-75.8061915511
NOTICE[Fri Aug 21 07:17:13 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 75.0-75.798084597
NOTICE[Fri Aug 21 20:07:18 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 75.0-75.803083842
NOTICE[Sat Aug 22 07:18:07 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 75.0-75.8021819349
NOTICE[Sat Aug 22 20:39:50 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 75.0-75.8130081301
NOTICE[Sun Aug 23 09:38:05 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 75.0-75.7959248647
NOTICE[Sun Aug 23 23:03:23 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 75.0-75.8171269815
NOTICE[Mon Aug 24 11:19:21 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 75.0-75.8074935401
NOTICE[Tue Aug 25 00:27:35 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 75.0-75.8045052293
NOTICE[Tue Aug 25 15:20:31 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 75.0-75.7932730446
NOTICE[Wed Aug 26 04:36:36 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 75.0-75.7979572295
NOTICE[Wed Aug 26 17:31:39 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 75.0-75.8008970046
NOTICE[Thu Aug 27 08:04:46 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 75.0-75.7952918721
NOTICE[Thu Aug 27 20:52:55 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 75.0-75.8046346958
NOTICE[Fri Aug 28 08:38:29 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 75.0-75.793398921
NOTICE[Fri Aug 28 21:05:16 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 75.0-75.803083842
NOTICE[Sat Aug 29 09:27:02 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 75.0-75.790513834
NOTICE[Sat Aug 29 21:29:35 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 75.0-75.806321561
NOTICE[Sun Aug 30 10:58:01 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 75.0-75.7916402787
NOTICE[Mon Aug 31 00:22:38 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 75.0-75.8065817067
NOTICE[Mon Aug 31 14:37:11 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 75.0-75.7926442613
NOTICE[Tue Sep 01 04:42:30 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 75.0-75.7877737514
NOTICE[Tue Sep 01 18:17:31 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 75.0-75.8001280205
NOTICE[Wed Sep 02 11:06:37 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 75.0-75.7790588969
NOTICE[Thu Sep 03 01:32:03 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 75.0-75.789016885
NOTICE[Thu Sep 03 15:39:07 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 75.0-75.7723200494
NOTICE[Fri Sep 04 04:26:31 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 75.0-75.7814942169
NOTICE[Fri Sep 04 17:18:05 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 75.0-75.786163522
NOTICE[Sat Sep 05 08:27:23 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 75.0-75.7733952049
NOTICE[Sun Sep 06 00:10:22 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 75.0-75.789016885
NOTICE[Sun Sep 06 13:17:37 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 75.0-75.7720815318
NOTICE[Mon Sep 07 02:33:43 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 75.0-75.7821054278
NOTICE[Mon Sep 07 19:05:33 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 75.0-75.7817385866
NOTICE[Tue Sep 08 12:00:57 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 75.0-75.7743534149
NOTICE[Wed Sep 09 03:31:56 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 75.0-75.7830853563
NOTICE[Wed Sep 09 16:43:36 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 75.0-75.7845598619
NOTICE[Thu Sep 10 07:05:09 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 75.0-75.786410821
NOTICE[Thu Sep 10 21:53:07 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 75.0-75.7949125596
NOTICE[Fri Sep 11 11:16:13 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 75.0-75.7807620237
NOTICE[Sat Sep 12 02:02:04 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 75.0-75.7880220646
NOTICE[Sat Sep 12 19:17:25 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 75.0-75.7991050024
NOTICE[Sun Sep 13 09:18:40 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 75.0-75.7915149596
NOTICE[Mon Sep 14 00:43:45 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 75.0-75.7910140801
NOTICE[Mon Sep 14 14:51:38 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 75.0-75.7653451707
NOTICE[Tue Sep 15 04:40:03 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 75.0-75.7744733581
NOTICE[Tue Sep 15 20:29:49 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 75.0-75.7836990596
NOTICE[Wed Sep 16 08:51:00 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 75.0-75.7712478791
NOTICE[Thu Sep 17 00:51:39 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 75.0-75.7806401249
NOTICE[Thu Sep 17 16:37:06 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 75.0-75.7667535654
NOTICE[Fri Sep 18 07:14:20 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 75.0-75.7697044335
NOTICE[Fri Sep 18 21:44:01 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 75.0-75.7765180929
NOTICE[Sat Sep 19 10:47:43 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 75.0-75.7639419404
NOTICE[Sun Sep 20 00:01:45 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 75.0-75.7785736531
NOTICE[Sun Sep 20 12:40:30 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 75.0-75.7598784195
NOTICE[Mon Sep 21 02:47:18 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 75.0-75.7741136399
NOTICE[Mon Sep 21 18:53:55 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 75.0-75.7747133561
NOTICE[Tue Sep 22 07:29:38 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 75.0-75.7718431615
NOTICE[Tue Sep 22 21:44:40 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 75.0-75.7779679477
NOTICE[Wed Sep 23 09:31:19 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 75.0-75.7687576876
NOTICE[Wed Sep 23 23:17:29 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 75.0-75.8089305938
NOTICE[Thu Sep 24 16:31:28 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 75.0-75.7689941556
NOTICE[Fri Sep 25 06:19:07 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 75.0-75.7685213649
NOTICE[Fri Sep 25 23:09:28 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 75.0-75.7756748371
NOTICE[Mon Sep 28 10:48:16 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 75.0-75.7619628162
NOTICE[Wed Sep 30 22:36:49 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 75.0-75.7662835249
NOTICE[Sat Oct 03 14:03:47 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 75.0-75.7474958888
NOTICE[Mon Oct 05 22:52:46 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 75.0-75.7619628162
NOTICE[Thu Oct 08 10:28:23 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 75.0-75.7560864963
NOTICE[Sat Oct 10 21:35:25 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 75.0-75.7685213649
NOTICE[Tue Oct 13 08:05:15 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 75.0-75.7647598654
NOTICE[Thu Oct 15 17:01:54 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 75.0-75.7633587786
NOTICE[Sat Oct 17 22:26:28 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 75.0-75.7763975155
NOTICE[Tue Oct 20 09:01:48 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 75.0-75.7675775253
NOTICE[Thu Oct 22 23:36:19 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 75.0-75.7737542556
NOTICE[Sun Oct 25 10:14:10 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 75.0-75.7540340823
NOTICE[Tue Oct 27 20:29:40 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 75.0-75.7610350076
NOTICE[Fri Oct 30 05:28:50 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 75.0-75.7642922654
Scanner 8
NOTICE[Tue Aug 18 15:29:50 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 87.0-87.796812749
NOTICE[Wed Aug 19 15:32:07 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 87.0-87.7982120051
NOTICE[Thu Aug 20 16:25:40 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 87.0-87.8
NOTICE[Fri Aug 21 11:39:00 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 87.0-87.7971938776
NOTICE[Sat Aug 22 09:01:44 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 87.0-87.7996161842
NOTICE[Sun Aug 23 04:29:56 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 87.0-87.8012820513
NOTICE[Mon Aug 24 00:37:08 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 87.0-87.8139345597
NOTICE[Mon Aug 24 20:58:20 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 87.0-87.804893754
NOTICE[Tue Aug 25 16:00:51 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 87.0-87.7928956549
NOTICE[Wed Aug 26 12:17:56 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 87.0-87.7907638779
NOTICE[Thu Aug 27 09:16:37 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 87.0-87.8036001286
NOTICE[Fri Aug 28 06:11:34 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 87.0-87.7969397514
NOTICE[Sat Aug 29 01:49:40 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 87.0-87.8011536613
NOTICE[Sat Aug 29 21:56:13 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 87.0-87.806321561
NOTICE[Sun Aug 30 16:32:01 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 87.0-87.7974481659
NOTICE[Mon Aug 31 11:05:24 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 87.0-87.7939028263
NOTICE[Tue Sep 01 07:38:06 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 87.0-87.7874015748
NOTICE[Wed Sep 02 07:19:25 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 87.0-87.7819831092
NOTICE[Thu Sep 03 02:25:15 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 87.0-87.7881462799
NOTICE[Thu Sep 03 21:20:25 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 87.0-87.7862871521
NOTICE[Fri Sep 04 17:38:23 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 87.0-87.7860399308
NOTICE[Sat Sep 05 12:33:50 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 87.0-87.7747133561
NOTICE[Sun Sep 06 08:44:50 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 87.0-87.7733952049
NOTICE[Mon Sep 07 03:52:30 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 87.0-87.7800312012
NOTICE[Mon Sep 07 23:14:48 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 87.0-87.7891414141
NOTICE[Tue Sep 08 17:37:06 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 87.0-87.78125
NOTICE[Wed Sep 09 11:40:31 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 87.0-87.785299199
NOTICE[Thu Sep 10 11:23:45 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 87.0-87.7823501799
NOTICE[Fri Sep 11 07:04:08 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 87.0-87.786410821
NOTICE[Sat Sep 12 10:23:01 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 87.0-87.7791803023
NOTICE[Sun Sep 13 10:06:52 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 87.0-87.7772423442
NOTICE[Mon Sep 14 09:05:57 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 87.0-87.7813720894
NOTICE[Tue Sep 15 04:40:59 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 87.0-87.7744733581
NOTICE[Wed Sep 16 04:29:30 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 87.0-87.7778469197
NOTICE[Thu Sep 17 00:35:21 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 87.0-87.7806401249
NOTICE[Thu Sep 17 23:14:03 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 87.0-87.7803964414
NOTICE[Fri Sep 18 19:43:11 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 87.0-87.7711289328
NOTICE[Sat Sep 19 16:54:48 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 87.0-87.7680491551
NOTICE[Sun Sep 20 12:59:18 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 87.0-87.7598784195
NOTICE[Mon Sep 21 14:29:45 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 87.0-87.7660487207
NOTICE[Tue Sep 22 10:24:57 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 87.0-87.7695859628
NOTICE[Wed Sep 23 07:39:13 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 87.0-87.7707723139
NOTICE[Thu Sep 24 05:12:35 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 87.0-87.7713668621
NOTICE[Fri Sep 25 01:54:21 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 87.0-87.7726781023
NOTICE[Sat Sep 26 03:46:53 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 87.0-87.7662835249
NOTICE[Mon Sep 28 21:29:44 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 87.0-87.7729169887
NOTICE[Thu Oct 01 16:29:33 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 87.0-87.7488392991
NOTICE[Sun Oct 04 06:25:13 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 87.0-87.7428316743
NOTICE[Wed Oct 07 01:55:28 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 87.0-87.7668711656
NOTICE[Fri Oct 09 18:21:26 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 87.0-87.7707723139
NOTICE[Mon Oct 12 05:14:25 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 87.0-87.7653451707
NOTICE[Wed Oct 14 21:22:12 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 87.0-87.7741136399
NOTICE[Sat Oct 17 12:05:16 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 87.0-87.7640586797
NOTICE[Tue Oct 20 04:18:07 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 87.0-87.7678132678
NOTICE[Thu Oct 22 19:06:09 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 87.0-87.7691124442
NOTICE[Sun Oct 25 14:51:27 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 87.0-87.7519927809
NOTICE[Wed Oct 28 06:57:26 2015]:Starting slice for percentiles 87.0-87.7562008469
```https://gitlab.torproject.org/legacy/trac/-/issues/17064scanner.9 in torflow/bwauth failing2020-06-13T16:19:26ZTom Rittertom@ritter.vgscanner.9 in torflow/bwauth failingI don't really have an idea of a cause here, but I noticed scanner.9 was failing. I have a 7.7GB log with debug messages, but here's the top and bottom 4000 lines:
top: http://pastebin.com/3fuEjkJ0
bottom: http://pastebin.com/7kF75asbI don't really have an idea of a cause here, but I noticed scanner.9 was failing. I have a 7.7GB log with debug messages, but here's the top and bottom 4000 lines:
top: http://pastebin.com/3fuEjkJ0
bottom: http://pastebin.com/7kF75asbhttps://gitlab.torproject.org/legacy/trac/-/issues/16923Torflow Measured=N value does not update for overloaded relays returning HTTP...2020-06-13T16:19:25ZTracTorflow Measured=N value does not update for overloaded relays returning HTTP 503symphony started heavily throttling bandwidth one week ago and is now extremely overloaded and practically unusable. The consensus weight has not dropped at all.
https://globe.torproject.org/#/relay/23C71BCC84DB5784E5BF91370FCA9069C660A...symphony started heavily throttling bandwidth one week ago and is now extremely overloaded and practically unusable. The consensus weight has not dropped at all.
https://globe.torproject.org/#/relay/23C71BCC84DB5784E5BF91370FCA9069C660A05F
Current consensus:
```
r symphony I8cbzITbV4Tlv5E3D8qQacZgoF8 YiN5jU5lvEgoiCEkzrk7EsE3YLg 2015-08-29 08:07:45 82.199.155.103 9001 9030
a [2a01:4a0:29::b28d:d6e8]:9002
s Fast HSDir Running Stable V2Dir Valid
v Tor 0.2.6.8
w Bandwidth=50800
```
The bandwidth authorities are serving up highly outdated measurements. Current authority votes:
longclaw
w Bandwidth=964 Measured=50800
maatuska
w Bandwidth=964 Measured=89400
gabelmoo
w Bandwidth=964 Measured=1
moria1
w Bandwidth=964 Measured=97400
Faravahar
w Bandwidth=964 Measured=1
**Trac**:
**Username**: someone_elsehttps://gitlab.torproject.org/legacy/trac/-/issues/16675BWauth longclaw outlier2020-06-13T16:19:25ZstarlightBWauth longclaw outlierThis ticket is somewhat vague due to my lack of
familiarity with the inner workings of TorFlow
and lack of access to a the system in question
It consists of an observed artifact that
may be attributable to one of the more
specific issues...This ticket is somewhat vague due to my lack of
familiarity with the inner workings of TorFlow
and lack of access to a the system in question
It consists of an observed artifact that
may be attributable to one of the more
specific issues. Please feel free to close
it out and/or note where it might belong.
For the last two weeks BWauths have been
generating measurements with apparently
improved rationality. Not sure what
change caused that but it's a very welcome
development.
On July 22 'longclaw' stopped updating
bandwidth measurements for four days,
but was restored about a day ago and
is now working.
'longclaw' has, in the last few hours,
produced an large outlier observation
for a Verizon FiOS relay relative to
a group of similar relays. Understanding
the cause may help further improve the
state of TorFlow.
The following relays all operate on
fast symmetrical FiOS connections in the
North Eastern US. Since the improved
behavior appeared, these relays generally
are measured with increasing bandwidth
in the order
```
longclaw
gabelmoo
maatuska
moria1
First a close-match and typical observation
as of 17:00 GMT 2015-07-27:
Binnacle
longclaw Bandwidth=8055 Measured=5350
gabelmoo Bandwidth=8055 Measured=8830
maatuska Bandwidth=8055 Measured=9370
moria1 Bandwidth=8055 Measured=21500
Now for the outlier, a relay very
similar to the above though it
appears to have 30% more bandwidth
available to the relay:
EmbraceTheChaos
longclaw Bandwidth=6986 Measured=33700
gabelmoo Bandwidth=6986 Measured=9090
maatuska Bandwidth=6986 Measured=9710
moria1 Bandwidth=6986 Measured=48200
The above measure appeared abruptly in
2015-07-27-09-00-00-vote-23D . . .
and in the prior vote was the more
rational, consistent and typical
Bandwidth=6986 Measured=4710
=====
Additional similar relays:
ZzZzZz
longclaw Bandwidth=6270 Measured=2530
gabelmoo Bandwidth=6270 Measured=5530
maatuska Bandwidth=6270 Measured=6420
moria1 Bandwidth=6270 Measured=16600
AGoodFellow
longclaw Bandwidth=4082 Measured=2620
gabelmoo Bandwidth=4082 Measured=4950
maatuska Bandwidth=4082 Measured=8730
moria1 Bandwidth=4082 Measured=9740
UrbanRelayUT
longclaw Bandwidth=3145 Measured=2540
gabelmoo Bandwidth=3145 Measured=2880
maatuska Bandwidth=3145 Measured=6740
moria1 Bandwidth=3145 Measured=5380
JumpPoint
longclaw Bandwidth=2777 Measured=2470
gabelmoo Bandwidth=2777 Measured=2800
maatuska Bandwidth=2777 Measured=4440
moria1 Bandwidth=2777 Measured=5340
12xBTM1
longclaw Bandwidth=2037 Measured=1020
gabelmoo Bandwidth=2037 Measured=2220
maatuska Bandwidth=2037 Measured=1860
moria1 Bandwidth=2037 Measured=3030
```
The though behind this ticket is it
may be worth analyzing specific examples
of apparently unsensible measurments
made by TorFlow. Due to the homogenous
and generally high-quality nature of
the Verizon FiOS network this is a
reasonable data point.Aaron GibsonAaron Gibsonhttps://gitlab.torproject.org/legacy/trac/-/issues/16667BWauth / scanner 'longclaw' measurments not updating since 7/222020-06-13T16:19:24ZstarlightBWauth / scanner 'longclaw' measurments not updating since 7/22At least some of the relay bandwidth measurements taken by 'longclaw' have not update since the first hour of 7/22/15 or for about 3.7 days. Reviewed values withing +/-60 lines of Binnacle (about a dozen total), which would seem to be a...At least some of the relay bandwidth measurements taken by 'longclaw' have not update since the first hour of 7/22/15 or for about 3.7 days. Reviewed values withing +/-60 lines of Binnacle (about a dozen total), which would seem to be a random sample.Aaron GibsonAaron Gibsonhttps://gitlab.torproject.org/legacy/trac/-/issues/16323Compatibility fixes for BWAuths on FreeBSD 102020-06-13T16:19:23ZJacob AppelbaumCompatibility fixes for BWAuths on FreeBSD 10I'm attempting to run BWAuth scanner code in a FreeBSD 10 jail as a test to see if it will work at all on FreeBSD 10. This assumes you've used ezjail to make a jailed machine - I used a jail behind a NAT for ease of use. The ezjail steps...I'm attempting to run BWAuth scanner code in a FreeBSD 10 jail as a test to see if it will work at all on FreeBSD 10. This assumes you've used ezjail to make a jailed machine - I used a jail behind a NAT for ease of use. The ezjail steps are out of scope but should be around three commands if NAT or a public IP is already assigned to your box.
First - we need to install some packages:
pkg install bash python27 py27-virtualenv py27-sqlite3 py27-sqlite3 sqlite3 py27-sqlite3dbm sqlite
pkg install automake libevent2 gmake openssl
I suggest the following patch:
```
diff --git a/NetworkScanners/BwAuthority/setup.sh b/NetworkScanners/BwAuthority/setup.sh
index 15ad931..d184060 100755
--- a/NetworkScanners/BwAuthority/setup.sh
+++ b/NetworkScanners/BwAuthority/setup.sh
@@ -1,4 +1,6 @@
-#!/bin/bash -e
+#!/usr/bin/env bash
+set -e
+set -x
SCANNER_DIR=$(dirname "$0")
SCANNER_DIR=$(readlink -f "$SCANNER_DIR")
@@ -35,7 +37,7 @@ then
git checkout release-0.2.6
./autogen.sh
./configure --disable-asciidoc
- make -j4
+ make
popd
fi
@@ -53,8 +55,8 @@ peep install -r $SCANNER_DIR/requirements.txt
# 6. Prepare cron script
cp cron.sh cron-mine.sh
-echo -e "45 0-23 * * * $SCANNER_DIR/cron-mine.sh" | crontab
-echo -e "@reboot $SCANNER_DIR/run_scan.sh\n`crontab -l`" | crontab
+echo -e "45 0-23 * * * $SCANNER_DIR/cron-mine.sh" | crontab -
+echo -e "@reboot $SCANNER_DIR/run_scan.sh\n`crontab -l`" | crontab -
echo "Prepared crontab. Current crontab: "
crontab -l
```
Then run everything as an unpriv user:
```
git clone https://git.torproject.org/torflow.git
cd torflow/NetworkScanners/BwAuthority
./setup.sh
```
If Tor fails to build, we'll see the following:
```
$ ./setup.sh
/usr/home/builder/torflow /usr/home/builder/torflow/NetworkScanners/BwAuthority
/usr/home/builder/torflow/NetworkScanners/BwAuthority
/usr/home/builder /usr/home/builder/torflow/NetworkScanners/BwAuthority
fatal: destination path 'tor' already exists and is not an empty directory.
```
Just remove Tor and ensure you have proper build deps:
```
rm -rf ../../../tor
```
If Tor fails to build:
```
--- src/or/src_or_libtor_testing_a-onion_ntor.o ---
CC src/or/src_or_libtor_testing_a-onion_ntor.o
--- src/or/src_or_libtor_testing_a-config_codedigest.o ---
CC src/or/src_or_libtor_testing_a-config_codedigest.o
src/or/config_codedigest.c:10:10: fatal error: 'or_sha1.i' file not found
#include "or_sha1.i"
^
1 error generated.
*** [src/or/src_or_libtor_testing_a-config_codedigest.o] Error code 1
make[1]: stopped in /usr/home/builder/tor
1 error
make[1]: stopped in /usr/home/builder/tor
*** [all] Error code 2
make: stopped in /usr/home/builder/tor
1 error
make: stopped in /usr/home/builder/tor
```
The above error means that make was running with `-j4` - please apply the above patch and try again.
```
In file included from src/module.c:24:
src/connection.h:33:10: fatal error: 'sqlite3.h' file not found
#include "sqlite3.h"
^
1 error generated.
error: command 'cc' failed with exit status 1
```
This means you need to tell cc where to find `sqlite3.h`
```
export CPPFLAGS=-I/usr/local/include
```
Run setup.sh again - it may error out like so:
```
crontab: usage error: file name must be specified for replace
usage: crontab [-u user] file
crontab [-u user] { -e | -l | -r }
```
This means you didn't apply the above patch for crontab (on BSD it expects {{{-}} or a file name but not an empty string, I guess).
```
cd torflow/NetworkScanners/BwAuthority
export CPPFLAGS=-I/usr/local/include
./setup.sh
```
The patch adds `-e` and `-x` which makes debugging easier - `-x` could be removed.
It looks like it may even work:
```
$ ./run_scan.sh
Waiting for 60 seconds to refresh tors...
Jun 09 20:28:31.505 [notice] Tor v0.2.6.8 (git-41db4bffd69f7de9) running on FreeBSD with Libevent 2.0.22-stable, OpenSSL 1.0.2a and Zlib 1.2.8.
Jun 09 20:28:31.505 [notice] Tor v0.2.6.8 (git-41db4bffd69f7de9) running on FreeBSD with Libevent 2.0.22-stable, OpenSSL 1.0.2a and Zlib 1.2.8.
Jun 09 20:28:31.505 [notice] Tor can't help you if you use it wrong! Learn how to be safe at https://www.torproject.org/download/download#warning
Jun 09 20:28:31.505 [notice] Tor can't help you if you use it wrong! Learn how to be safe at https://www.torproject.org/download/download#warning
Jun 09 20:28:31.505 [notice] Read configuration file "/usr/home/builder/torflow/NetworkScanners/BwAuthority/./data/tor.1/torrc".
Jun 09 20:28:31.505 [notice] Read configuration file "/usr/home/builder/torflow/NetworkScanners/BwAuthority/./data/tor.2/torrc".
Jun 09 20:28:31.513 [notice] Opening Socks listener on 127.0.0.1:9120
Jun 09 20:28:31.513 [notice] Opening Socks listener on 127.0.0.1:9110
Jun 09 20:28:31.513 [notice] Opening Control listener on 127.0.0.1:9121
Jun 09 20:28:31.513 [notice] Opening Control listener on 127.0.0.1:9111
Jun 09 20:28:31.513 [warn] Fixing permissions on directory ./data/tor.2
Jun 09 20:28:31.513 [warn] Fixing permissions on directory ./data/tor.1
```https://gitlab.torproject.org/legacy/trac/-/issues/16258Add "libssl-dev" and "C compiler" to bwauth dependencies2020-06-13T16:19:23ZNima FatemiAdd "libssl-dev" and "C compiler" to bwauth dependenciesI just ran the new bwauth setup on a brand new debian machine out of curiosity, and realized it tries to build tor from git and misses these two dependencies.
I just added it to the setup.sh script and attached a patch. feel free to edi...I just ran the new bwauth setup on a brand new debian machine out of curiosity, and realized it tries to build tor from git and misses these two dependencies.
I just added it to the setup.sh script and attached a patch. feel free to edit/improve if necessary.Aaron GibsonAaron Gibsonhttps://gitlab.torproject.org/legacy/trac/-/issues/15876bwauth: load certs from disk2020-06-13T16:19:22Zweasel (Peter Palfrader)bwauth: load certs from diskHi,
with python2.7 validating ssl certs, bwauth broke for me since I don't trust all the certs systemwide.
I have patched my version to load optional trust anchors from disk.
https://people.torproject.org/~weasel/.git/torflow.git shou...Hi,
with python2.7 validating ssl certs, bwauth broke for me since I don't trust all the certs systemwide.
I have patched my version to load optional trust anchors from disk.
https://people.torproject.org/~weasel/.git/torflow.git should have my tree.https://gitlab.torproject.org/legacy/trac/-/issues/15238Improve or replace TorFlow2020-06-13T16:19:22ZNick MathewsonImprove or replace TorFlowTorFlow is not so hard to game; we should make it harder to game, or replace it with something harder to game. Aaron, Rob, and Paul have some interesting preliminary designs for a Big Thing Indeed, but last I heard it still needed quite...TorFlow is not so hard to game; we should make it harder to game, or replace it with something harder to game. Aaron, Rob, and Paul have some interesting preliminary designs for a Big Thing Indeed, but last I heard it still needed quite a bit of work. So is our best option improving the TorFlow we have today?