snowflake's 0.0.3.0 dummy address means rate limits are skipped means BW controller events show no bandwidth used
Snowflake's default bridge pretends to be on 0.0.3.0. It's a dummy address since snowflake-client knows how to connect to the right bridge and ignores the address that Tor tells it.
But my Tor client still uses that bridge address to make decisions. For example, connection_is_rate_limited() decides "no, it isn't rate limited", because tor_addr_is_internal() says 0.0.3.0 is essentially part of localhost. And that choice has a cascading effect where when I attach my nyx to Tor Browser to graph bandwidth use (
nyx -i 9151), the BW events all say "0 0" because my Tor hasn't sent or received any non-internal bytes.
The quick fix is to keep using a dummy address, but to pick one that isn't an internal address. I confirmed that if I change snowflake's dummy address to 18.104.22.168, then connection_is_rate_limited() decides it's external, my BW events work again, and nyx gives me graphs. That is, Tor is smart enough to know that even though the connection is from the Tor client to the localhost snowflake client, the connection is "really" to the (non-localhost) destination bridge address.
I confess that I don't know which "apparently routable but don't worry we won't actually connect to it, probably" address is the best choice here. :/
The longer term answer is to have some other way to signal that it's a dummy address, or to change the PT interface so we don't need the fake address. But I don't think we need to wait for the longer term answer here.
The reason I noticed this issue is because I am pondering lobbying for the Tor Browser folks to give me a tiny bandwidth graph (or activity spinner) somewhere in the browser, because I got a super slow snowflake, but I was still getting 5-10KBytes/s, and my page did load after like 90 seconds, but if I hadn't been staring at the
2020/03/23 09:33:05 Traffic Bytes (in|out): 9018 | 10981 -- (27 OnMessages, 24 Sends)
lines I would have assumed that it was wedged.